There is something special about pornstars that look like the “girl next door.” Maybe it’s their innocence or because they haven’t been fucked by three hundred raging cocks from the Sparta photoshoot yet. All we know is that our dicks get titanium hard when amateurs start undressing.
Anyhow, after making lists about the best new pornstars and such, it is time for the very similar but different (go figure) list, gentlemen, allow to me reveal our favorite, amateur shows and porn stars from 2020 to 2025.
As the years went by, we added more girls who would still be considered amateurs in 2025. The other top 10s list now includes what we consider professionals. They might have been inexperienced 5 years ago, but for the up-to-date list, RedBled is your solution.
22Keilani Kita
Slightly uncomfortable with large cocks, Keilani behaves like your typical amateur. Notice the eye contact and how she keeps looking for feedback. Am I sucking dick good? Even the love of Kita’s life didn’t get as much attention as a random dude from a porn set. Nevertheless, she started a porn career at the age of 21, and ten months later, she still aspires to become more than an unknown name.
How long will that last? That’s what separates inexperienced pornstars from professionals. Their hunger for money and “new life” is stronger than public reactions, insulting comments, or unmemorable porn scenes. Let’s see what changes in a year or two and If Keilani Kita continues to perform.
21Scarlet Chase
In the early 2000s, all sluts faked their orgasms on camera. Then the far has died down and is reserved for the dishonest camwhores that pretend to squirt, have a brain aneurism, or pass out. What does that have to do with Chase? It’s rare to find a cute amateur pornstar that is truly into sex and does so consistently. She is a genuine breed of epic fuck meat.
The best, and, let’s be honest, the hottest women in all relationships are those who enjoy cum. As soon as a boyfriend finishes cumming, Bellringer’s eyes light up with fire. We can feel how badly she wants to eat every gulp of it.
→ Source: Mofos.com.
20MollyRedWolf
At first, we thought her name was a joke, but no, she is called MollyRedWolf, which I am sure is her real first, last, and middle name. So what can you expect from the amateur slut with a nickname like that? If you don’t get it, I have bad news for you, bro; you might have some chromosome imbalance. She loves to swallow cum, enjoys sucking dick, and is a nice little amateur to join our best list.
On a side note, it’s easy to deepthroat small dicks, and MollyRedWolf would choke on some of our readers’ giant cocks because everyone has one. Right?
→ Source: Mofos.com.
19Aften Opal
After gaining some traction, Opal got rid of the ugly glasses and became a hot amateur pornstar who gives you a hard-on from the first few seconds of the video. It is one of the best angles; we wish that he had used more than one finger. She is not a virgin, so why not shove your fist in there? I doubt that Aften Opal even feels a thing. That’s if Aften’s face is not showing! Then it’s all fun and games. Maybe that’s a tactic you can also use. I am not saying she is ugly; it’s the opposite. However, those fucking glasses need to go now.
Small tits, a flat stomach (no abs), shyness in some scenes, and an occasional black dick. She also enjoys choking and is a fan of video games. Is this a neckbeard-perfect amateur, or what?
→ Source: RealityKings.com.
18Jill Kassidy
Jill is a bit different kind of amateur as she is into hardcore fucking, so this is the equivalent of your crazy ex-girlfriend that you have been abusing for the last few years. Ass to mouth and amateur does not sound like my bread and butter, but she interested me. Oh, and she is also from Texas, so you can’t expect the ass that is not exactly as flat as the bottom of your frying pan.
Why is she like that? I have no clue. I wonder if instead of asking to draw some pictures or identify patterns (like psychologists do), we could judge female characters from the way they suck or hold dick.
→ Source: JulesJordan.com.
17Ashly Anderson
How fun does that look? A couple made for one another. Judging from choking, saliva, and her love for aggressive sex, we have an abusive-loving amateur with daddy issues and a curly-haired stud who enjoys choking. I’d give one of my livers to switch places with him; these amateurs are my favorite kind.
If we had to pick our favorite thing about Ashly Anderson, that would be her butthole. There is nothing in this world like banging women through the ass, showing them who is a boss and a slave. The facial expressions in this scene would go well with the anal scene.
16Nola Xica
As crazy as bananas and without the inconvenience of loose dick skin, Nola Xica can pull some magic tricks of her own. Her circumcised boyfriend’s penetration angles are questionable and can seem clunky, but it’s part of the “homemade sex tape” charm, and I stand behind this video. Just don’t doubt their shows since things do pick up later. Having said that, did she check if the dick was in?
Juicing that pussy from the inside, enjoying the rearview, and then there are bunny ears… This must have been an Easter special, or at least I hope so.
You can find this pornstar on Pornhub, and you can get premium for free here.
15Devon Green
A puffy rear in a doggystyle position stands behind your dick and the rest of Devon’s body. No need to talk; just do your thing. Amateurs are simple species and go with the flow. The more adventurous ones have a threesome, while the rest just call themselves whores and go to a nightclub for a one-night stand.
Devon Green fucks better than many of your ex-girlfriends, we can tell. Even if her pussy is dry in this scene, the guy is far too excited here, and there are no virgins here. His dick is oozing with pre-cum, saliva, lube, or whatever else is there. She’s a cute little mermaid to get your stamina levels up.
→ Source: Mofos.com.
14Sweetie Fox
Now, this is the amateur that you shall see soon in the mainstream porn sites, as there is just no way that big companies won’t drop a six-figure check to have her on board. Currently, the couple is filming themselves and trying to build their brand. So, enjoy a duo of amateur “pornstars” that should help you to get your one-time fix when searching for hot newcomers.
She is one of the hottest girls out there, and we would love for Sweetie to do mainstream. But, unfortunately, this is very unlikely, at least according to her agent.
→ Source: Mofos.com.
13Jenny Blighe
It was a bit unexpected, but here we go. A redhead and a good looking one? Someone should call the FBI, as she is clearly from outer space. In all seriousness, we just made our best amateur list even better, as it now covers it all.
Lesbians, anal, facials, and more than enough hair colors, including redheads, blondes and brunettes. It’s like a complete package, right? Anyhow, going back to Jenny, she is fucking hot; she is an amateur and loves all dick. There is nothing else that you need to figure out.
If any love amateur pornstars, be sure to check the best amateur sites list that we have compiled.
12Kissa Sins
Behold, the ass of a goddess. Filming together with Sins, Kissa is one of the amateurs you can’t get enough of. Yes, the video above does not exactly do Sins justice, but we thought it was fucking hot anyway. Oh, and her “first name” is just adorable; it makes you think about kissing her pussy, and then pounding the asshole until it splits open.
A less active porn viewer could mistake her for someone very famous, but it’s all due to her last name. So you see, Johnny Sins is a professional performer, not Kisa.
→ Source: SinsLife.com.
11Lexi Luna
One of the worst and best things about amateur actresses is that it is hard to find many hot videos. Fortunately, Luna did shoot with Mofos and a few other brands. Her tits are out of this world, and the perky nipples add to the already perfect look. Unfortunately, I would not be able to fuck her in any shape or form since I have already ejaculated twice just by filling the Word document with text about her.
One of the few amateur pornstars that recently went mainstream and now shoots amateur porn professionally.
→ Source: MomsTeachSex.com.
10Lila Love
If we had to pick Jessica Alba’s pornstar lookalike, which is even hotter, Lila Love would be it. But even without similarities to a famous Hollywood actress, thousands of other things bring us joy. The casual nature of Lila is almost magnetic, and we can only hope that she doesn’t destroy the beauty with obnoxious tits or fillers.
I’d say that Lila Love could be Riley’s successor one day since her tiny figure and perky tits somehow work, creating a unifying jerking-off experience. That’s a huge selling point, folks.
9Cherry Crush
Jesus Christ, almighty. We love amateur anal videos, and Cherry loves to get her cherry popped. So this is like the best a man can get, right? Minus the razors (implying a well-known commercial). Just look at her asshole and how she moves; it is as amateur as you can get, and it is fucking hot.
Thanks to God, she does have a full site dedicated to her asshole pounding, blowjobs, and old-school vaginal action. The truly fantastic anal scene, skinny pussy, and tight third hole. Push it deeper, baby.
→ Source: MyCherruCrush.com.
8Lana Rhoades
Let’s add something spicy to the mix, someone who looks like an amateur yet fucks like a sex hero with 50 years of experience. Instead of a blue-ribbon award, however, Lana leaves jizz zone with a red gape, which too is an honor. A stunning brunette with an open mind took Keiran’s dick, relaxed her butt-cheeks and let him do the rest. It also works great for the crew who don’t require to apply copious amounts of makeup or do tricky lighting.
Among Lana’s first videos were lesbian “experiments” yet it quickly dawned upon everyone that this woman is better at handling sausages. Watch the scene because Lana Rhoades will soon turn into a professional slut.
→ Source: RealityKings.com.
7Mandy Flores
Oh boy, amateur anal is the best thing that can happen to a healthy man, and thanks to Mandy, she has been fulfilling everyone’s dream for the last few years. Nice round ass, a cute face that does not remind you of a whore (yet), and overall, a pretty decent amateur. Did I already tell you she likes getting fucked in the ass? So, amateur plus ass equals a good time.
For me, the most frustrating part is getting my dick down the butt for the first time, especially if there is no lube. Although, sometimes, it takes 5 to 10 minutes to push that shit in. But for Mandy, this is not the case since her brown hole received perfect training beforehand.
→ Source: Mofos.com.
6Leah Gotti
Facials and amateurs, name a funnier duo. Unfortunately, some are allergic to the cum and give hilarious and repulsive reactions. Now, watch Leah (on the right). She seems to love that shit and tries to get every single drop of the cum like a StarCraft worker tries to gather all the minerals.
These amateurish smiles make your dick harder than the nails that plowed through Jesus’ hands. I love Leah. She could write a book about the survival and nutritional value of male semen.
→ Source: Mofos.com.
5Luxury Girl
Pulling serious numbers in views and likes, the sexiest amateur you will find in 2025, hell, even 2030, is Luxury Girl. Yes, we are that confident! No other slut will beat her, at least in the next 12 months.
She did a few test scenes in 2019, but that was it. After that, Luxury Girl slowed down with new releases on mainstream sites and realigned her priorities in life. Thankfully, that was for the better, as a few years later, all hell (and her Russian butthole) broke loose. She seriously blew up in 2022 and became a major player in town.
4Lucy Cat
Regarding public amateur porn, Lucy is one of our favorites. This girl has no shame and can be fucked pretty much anywhere. Shipping malls, beaches, streets, behind the dumpster, you name it, and she will deliver. Having a hot blonde look gives her a lot of extra points, too. A true gem if you are into public sex and inexperienced sluts.
There are dozens of awesome amateur porn videos on the MDH channel (part of Lucy Cat) with our blond pornstar that I do recommend checking out. It’s the thrill that’s all the drill.
→ Source: MyDirtyHobby.com.
3Karmen Bella
I got 99 virgins, but this bitch isn’t one. Don’t freak out yet; this is just roleplay and has nothing to do with religion or other sensitive matters (minus the dick and clitoris). His dick is not that massive, but it has some trouble sliding in; it looks like Karmen Bella is still at the amateur pornstar stage, where you don’t get wet easily. I’m still confused if she is into this whole BDSM sex thing or not. In this scene, Karmen had the driest pussy of any woman. Like these dunes that appear at the beginning of the video.
Thankfully, her later performances were much better, and for middle eastern porn, Karmen Bella is great. Raised in the USA but has Indian and Polish genes.
→ Source: PornFidelity.com.
2Ivy Wolfe
Ivy Wolfe spends most of her time with her mouth wide open, hunting for fresh cocks and masculine men to take advantage of her. Loves to be abused, fucked hard, and with lots of hair-pulling. Natural ginger, elastic pussy owner, and a petite body.
The best thing about Ivy is that she is naturally good-looking and can still pull off the amateur pornstar look without looking like a professional whore. She owns one of the best of all pussies I have seen. Plenty of skin, great tightness, and wetness. The ass crack is also interesting, although believe me when I say that we have already searched for her anal videos, and there were no results.
→ Source: CastingCouch-X.com.
1Michelle Taylor
Some amateurs look like shit, with bland or no make-up, which is fine in some scenarios. However, for quality porn, this needs to be fixed, and here is an example with Michelle Taylor to prove our point. It looks like a true pornstar, albeit new. She needs to keep on going! We see plenty of potential and can guarantee that Michelle will be one of the top pornstars in the next 5 years.
Fantastic attitude, a unique look, no awful tattoos or bad nicknames, and multiple pleasure-giving holes. I am super excited for Michelle and can’t wait to see more. She is similar to Sasha Gray, and we know how famous that performer was.
→ Source: CastingCouch-X.com.
Watch porn talent before it goes mainstream. The hottest amateur pornstars from 2025 and last year. Links to full scenes, sexy GIFs, and true amateur action.
